List of hard to distinguish FWB and 4th Edition Cards
Moderators: cataclysm80, hammr7, l0qii, Apocalypse2K, berkumps, dragsamou, mystical_tutor, pp
-
- Librarities Legend
- Posts: 709
- Joined: Fri Aug 09, 2013 1:09 pm
- Location: Florida
There is a comparison picture of a German FWB Swamp, German 4th Swamp, & German Introductory Two-Player Set Swamp in this thread.palaueb wrote:@Neuron, can you post a swamp please?
http://www.magiclibrarities.net/forum/v ... c&start=45
(scroll to bottom of page after clicking on link)
There is also info there about how to tell them apart.
Hopefully this will help until the info can be posted here in this thread.
Tav
according to these pictures:
these explanation are wrong.
Blauer Urknall (Blue Elemental Blast): FWB rulestext doesn't mention "Deiner Wahl" ("target"). 4th: Does mention "Deiner Wahl"
Roter Urknall (Red Elemental Blast): FWB rulestext doesn't mention "Deiner Wahl" ("target"). 4th: Does mention "Deiner Wahl"
The difference is in text alignment, but none version says "deiner Wahl" Maybe something is mixed up here with the 2PS Set ? But i dont know if these cards were in 2PS. Another difference is, one version uses the word "bleibende", the other does not.
these explanation are wrong.
Blauer Urknall (Blue Elemental Blast): FWB rulestext doesn't mention "Deiner Wahl" ("target"). 4th: Does mention "Deiner Wahl"
Roter Urknall (Red Elemental Blast): FWB rulestext doesn't mention "Deiner Wahl" ("target"). 4th: Does mention "Deiner Wahl"
The difference is in text alignment, but none version says "deiner Wahl" Maybe something is mixed up here with the 2PS Set ? But i dont know if these cards were in 2PS. Another difference is, one version uses the word "bleibende", the other does not.
Added:
Auferstehung der Toten (Raise Dead): FWB: Last word in the first line "dem" 4th: Last word in the first line "Deinem".
Belebung der Toten (Animate Dead): FWB: Very small font, six lines of text. 4th: Eight lines of text.
Knochenmauer (Wall of Bones): FWB: Word division in flavour text "let-zten" 4th: No word division.
Mondschatten (Bad Moon): FWB: Word division "erhal-ten" 4th: No word division.
Terror: FWB: First word in text "Bringe" 4th: First word in text "Begrabe".
Todesgewebe (Deathlace): FWB: Very small font, last word in text "Karte" 4th: Last word "Ziels".
Auferstehung der Toten (Raise Dead): FWB: Last word in the first line "dem" 4th: Last word in the first line "Deinem".
Belebung der Toten (Animate Dead): FWB: Very small font, six lines of text. 4th: Eight lines of text.
Knochenmauer (Wall of Bones): FWB: Word division in flavour text "let-zten" 4th: No word division.
Mondschatten (Bad Moon): FWB: Word division "erhal-ten" 4th: No word division.
Terror: FWB: First word in text "Bringe" 4th: First word in text "Begrabe".
Todesgewebe (Deathlace): FWB: Very small font, last word in text "Karte" 4th: Last word "Ziels".
Yes it's correct!
FWB is also Much darker than 4th edition.
That's is more visible in white,blue and green cards.
As you wrote ( confirmed in another vintage italian site) an other difference is the sign over "i" and "j". 4th edition have round dot while FWB (Or as we usually call "seconda edizione Or second edition" have slash marks.
Can i submit pics from ipad?
Cannot find the button to attach "richiamo di Hurkyl"
FWB is also Much darker than 4th edition.
That's is more visible in white,blue and green cards.
As you wrote ( confirmed in another vintage italian site) an other difference is the sign over "i" and "j". 4th edition have round dot while FWB (Or as we usually call "seconda edizione Or second edition" have slash marks.
Can i submit pics from ipad?
Cannot find the button to attach "richiamo di Hurkyl"
cataclysm80 wrote:Good idea Ron, this will be a Great thread!
Of coarse, the first thing to do when trying to identify which of these sets a card is from is to check the set list. Many cards are only in one of the two sets. For example, there are no dual lands in 4th Edition.
The next thing to look for is a lowercase i or j in the card name. FWB uses slash marks above those letters, while 4th uses more of a round dot. Here is a picture.
Here is a link to an older thread with more tips on how to tell these sets apart. http://www.magiclibrarities.net/forum/v ... php?t=2383
The above tips will help in identifying most cards from these sets, but some cards are more difficult, and this thread is about those difficult cards.
Ron, is your list above a complete list of the cards which are in both sets but do not contain an i or j in the card name?
Tav
Re: List of hard to distinguish FWB and 4th Edition Cards
White
armageddon FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321277
Armageddon FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320970
Armageddon 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322124
Armatura sacra FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321278
Armatura sacra FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320971
Armatura sacra 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322148
Avatar FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321279
Avatar FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320972
Avatar 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322159
Castello FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321283
Castello FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320976
Castello 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322131
Forza Sacra FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321295
Forza sacra FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320988
Forza sacra 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322149
Karma FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321302
Karma FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320995
Karma 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322151
Pegaso delle mese FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321309
Pegaso delle mese FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321002
Pegaso delle mese 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322154
armageddon FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321277
Armageddon FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320970
Armageddon 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322124
Armatura sacra FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321278
Armatura sacra FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320971
Armatura sacra 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322148
Avatar FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321279
Avatar FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320972
Avatar 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322159
Castello FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321283
Castello FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320976
Castello 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322131
Forza Sacra FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321295
Forza sacra FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320988
Forza sacra 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322149
Karma FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321302
Karma FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320995
Karma 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322151
Pegaso delle mese FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321309
Pegaso delle mese FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321002
Pegaso delle mese 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322154
All cards from
FBB set search in this list :
http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _7633_8960
FWB : http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _7633_8959
4th : http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _7633_8973
That's the most complete italian website with i think the 99% of correct image!!!! However write if you find something to verify. It's a pleasure for me guys.
Don't own any copyright
FBB set search in this list :
http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _7633_8960
FWB : http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _7633_8959
4th : http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _7633_8973
That's the most complete italian website with i think the 99% of correct image!!!! However write if you find something to verify. It's a pleasure for me guys.
Don't own any copyright
It's difficult for me to classify "incAnalare energia".
The first and second photos have the same exactly text but different color.
The second if i consider only the colour must be 4th...but i'm not sure
The second and third photos have a different text but same colour.
Don't know if the second photo is 4th....
The first and second photos have the same exactly text but different color.
The second if i consider only the colour must be 4th...but i'm not sure
The second and third photos have a different text but same colour.
Don't know if the second photo is 4th....
Re: List of hard to distinguish FWB and 4th Edition Cards
Hibox1985 wrote:White
armageddon FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321277
Armageddon FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320970
Armageddon 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322124
Armatura sacra FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321278
Armatura sacra FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320971
Armatura sacra 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322148
Avatar FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321279
Avatar FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320972
Avatar 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322159
Castello FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321283
Castello FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320976
Castello 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322131
Forza Sacra FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321295
Forza sacra FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320988
Forza sacra 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322149
Karma FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321302
Karma FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=320995
Karma 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322151
Pegaso delle mese FBB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321309
Pegaso delle mese FWB http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=321002
Pegaso delle mese 4th http://www.cardgame-club.it/index.php?m ... _id=322154
None of the links are working, please post pics directly on the forum.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 81 guests