The Magic Librarities

Seems it was miscut enough so you can see the white of the edge of the sheet.

Interestingly, the cut looks a little rough on the top left and bottom right. That bottom corner (back left bottom corner) you can even sort of feel a lip on it. I've had this stored away for a long time.

front http://imgur.com/hSm1lY5
back http://imgur.com/y82lDEL
back2 http://imgur.com/C3Y87Ye
mirror focus front http://imgur.com/u7HJvyQ
mirror focus back http://imgur.com/QYWeqNf

A pretty cool miscut I've turned down some small offers on in the past. Might be willing to part with now for something I'd play. I was wondering how difficult it'd be to find 3 more but Ben C told me "I have never seen a similar Revised miscut, though" so I dunno.

Anyone?

Surprised that Ben hasn't seen a similar revised miscut. Maybe they're out there, but not all of them have the same jacked up corners. Here's one I have that could (in theory) be from the same sheet:


I'm not sure what you consider "low" offers, but it's not a terribly exciting miscut from the front, which is pretty important when considering playable misprints. Not saying that it isn't worth much more than some random common with the same cut, but this is not how I'd choose to pimp out my dark rituals. Guess if I needed one to complete a playeset of miscuts I'd use it until I found a better one. Still a very nice card though!

TheJGit wrote:Surprised that Ben hasn't seen a similar revised miscut. Maybe they're out there, but not all of them have the same jacked up corners. Here's one I have that could (in theory) be from the same sheet:


I'm not sure what you consider "low" offers, but it's not a terribly exciting miscut from the front, which is pretty important when considering playable misprints. Not saying that it isn't worth much more than some random common with the same cut, but this is not how I'd choose to pimp out my dark rituals. Guess if I needed one to complete a playeset of miscuts I'd use it until I found a better one. Still a very nice card though!

the initial small offers were like single digits. Ben said it was probably worth $20-$50. I then had an offer of $50 in trade for it if it was sleeve playable but never showed it to that guy in person.

LandDestroyer wrote: the initial small offers were like single digits. Ben said it was probably worth $20-$50. I then had an offer of $50 in trade for it if it was sleeve playable but never showed it to that guy in person.

Ben's estimate is definitely in the correct ballpark :)

TheJGit wrote:

LandDestroyer wrote: the initial small offers were like single digits. Ben said it was probably worth $20-$50. I then had an offer of $50 in trade for it if it was sleeve playable but never showed it to that guy in person.

Ben's estimate is definitely in the correct ballpark :)

It generally is :)

Would this kind of miscut have any value or do they need to have front side errors to be worth anything?

Chad2012 wrote: ↑

Sat Jun 09, 2018 4:42 pm

Would this kind of miscut have any value or do they need to have front side errors to be worth anything?

It won't bring in as much as one that's miscut on the front and normal on the back but what you have there is certainly valuable =D>

I never did post my revised rit for sale. Was considering letting go of it. Anyone have any guesses on updated price given current market?

if you see my pics on the back you can see the sheet edge

front http://imgur.com/hSm1lY5
back http://imgur.com/y82lDEL
back2 http://imgur.com/C3Y87Ye
mirror focus front http://imgur.com/u7HJvyQ
mirror focus back http://imgur.com/QYWeqNf

LandDestroyer wrote: ↑

Fri Feb 11, 2022 1:35 am

I never did post my revised rit for sale. Was considering letting go of it. Anyone have any guesses on updated price given current market?

if you see my pics on the back you can see the sheet edge

front http://imgur.com/hSm1lY5
back http://imgur.com/y82lDEL
back2 http://imgur.com/C3Y87Ye
mirror focus front http://imgur.com/u7HJvyQ
mirror focus back http://imgur.com/QYWeqNf

Unfortunately Revised miscuts with evenly miscut front and back do not raise that much interest, since many many many uncut sheets of revised were given out and cut as miscut on purpose by speculators. Yours might be one of it. Even if you opened it yourself once, there is nearly no way to proof it and distinguish it from the many "Non factory cut" miscuts available in the wild, depending on how good or bad it was cut. The fact its a "twisted" miscut is a good thing at least, since this cant be faked that easily. However, it does not show another card on front and there is just considered "off center" for display purpose, despite the fact it shows sheetedge on the back. In summary, it might raise less that you probably hope for, so i suggest you rather keep it.